Uncommon Descent Serving The Intelligent Design Community

Journal publishes attack on another journal

Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

We thought that kind of thing only happened to us ID folk. We’re used to it.

Any mediocrity can make his name in Tax-Funded Science attacking us.

You pay, you enjoy. Or not. You pay anyway.

But now this from Discover:

A psychiatry journal, the Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease (JNMD), has just published a remarkable attack on another journal, Frontiers in Psychology. Here’s the piece: it’s by the JNMD’s own Statistics Editor. In it, he writes that:

To be perfectly candid, the reader needs to be informed that the journal that published the Lakens (2013) article, Frontiers in Psychology, is one of an increasing number of journals that charge exorbitant publication fees in exchange for free open access to published articles. Some of the author costs are used to pay reviewers, causing one to question whether the process is always unbiased, as is the desideratum. For further information, the reader is referred to the following Web site: http://www.frontiersin.org/Psychology/fees.

The back-story here is that a group of researchers wrote a letter to JNMD alleging several errors in a 2014 paper about psychotherapy for psychosis. More.

Whatever.

Could the virus be spreading?

Comments
No disputin' here, Bob O'H at 1. But psychology is a troubled field anyway. ;)News
April 6, 2015
April
04
Apr
6
06
2015
01:33 AM
1
01
33
AM
PDT
Wow. That is utterly, utterly bizarre. There must be a back-story to the back-story.Bob O'H
April 6, 2015
April
04
Apr
6
06
2015
01:22 AM
1
01
22
AM
PDT

Leave a Reply