Uncommon Descent

Archive for June, 2008

29 June 2008

Understanding Intelligent Design — now available at Amazon.com!

William Dembski

Understanding Intelligent Design: Everything You Need to Know in Plain Language, which I coauthored with Sean McDowell, and for which his father Josh McDowell wrote a bang-up foreword, is now available at Amazon.com (click here).
The book is geared at Christian young people (junior high and high schoolers) as well as for Church groups (e.g., [...]

28 June 2008

Biological Neg-Entropy

GilDodgen

Some of you might have heard that Jonathan Schaeffer and his team at the U. of Alberta recently solved the game of checkers. It made big news in the computer science world.
I first met Jon at the First Computer Olympiad in London (organized by the famous David Levy of chess and computer-chess fame) at which [...]

28 June 2008

Expelled: Why are Americans allowed to care so much about freedom?, and other thoughts

O'Leary

Two nights ago, I finally saw the Expelled film.
I had become almost proprietorial about the widely denounced #5 political documentary.  I had first broken the story of its existence last August. I watched it pitch and roll through accusations of trickery, a threatened lawsuit over plagiarism and a real one over intellectual property, production delays [...]

27 June 2008

Zillions of Universes

O'Leary

I am completely envious and I, like, totally admit it. This guy Steve Burri (one of the fellows in this picture) is way better than me when it comes to sending up goofy “zillions of universes” cosmology:
The scientists and researchers employed in my secret basement laboratory are quite an ecclectic bunch. We have staff that [...]

27 June 2008

Oldie but Goodie: Berlinski’s Open Letter to the Amazing Randi

William Dembski

Back in 2005, David Berlinski responded to James Randi’s attempt to bribe the Smithsonian to suppress showing THE PRIVILEGED PLANET. Enjoy Berlinski’s response by clicking here.

27 June 2008

Louisiana Science Education Act — Gov. Jindal signs off on it!

William Dembski

I just received this press release from Seattle’s Discovery Institute:
Governor Bobby Jindal Signs Historic Science Education Act On Evolution and Education
Baton Rouge – Louisiana Governor Bobby Jindal signed into law the Louisiana Science Education Act, ensuring the state’s teachers their right to teach the scientific evidence both for and against Darwinian evolution.
“The bill is [...]

27 June 2008

Rights for Apes in Spain

William Dembski

Here is one consequence of evolution being used to justify strict continuity between humans and other forms of life. Discovery Institute’s persistent stress on humans being made in the image of God and that not being a privilege extended to the rest of the animal world makes more and more sense. This action in Spain [...]

25 June 2008

Making genetic history - Jerry A. Coyne

Mario A. Lopez

BOOK REVIEWED-In Pursuit of the Gene: From Darwin to DNA
by James Schwartz
Harvard University Press: 2008. 384 pp.
Fruitful collaborations were formed in Thomas Hunt Morgan’s fly genetics lab.
When I was a student, ‘doing genetics’ meant crossing two different strains or species. Now it means sequencing DNA, preferably human. Between these two poles lies the history of [...]

25 June 2008

First paragraph of Lenski paper contains an error

DaveScot

I started reading Lenski’s full paper myself to see what raw data was provided and I got no farther than the first paragraph beyond the abstract when I encountered a bias error that a chance worshipper would never notice. My emphasis:
At its core, evolution involves a profound tension between
random and deterministic processes. Natural selection
works [...]

25 June 2008

IQ and ID

DaveScot

Uncommon Descent member AussieID brought up the point in my previous article that belief in God tends to fall off with increasing IQ. I countered with the point that the very highest IQs tend to come back around, not full circle to a belief in a personal God (such as the God of Abraham), [...]

24 June 2008

The Schlafly-Lenski Briefwechsel

William Dembski

PZ Myers at the Panda’s Thumb draws our attention to an exchange between Andrew Schlafly and Richard Lenski (the impetus for the exchange is Lenski’s work running tens of thousands of generations of E. coli to produce some interesting, or not so interesting, evolution as the case may be). Myers thinks Lenski gets the better [...]

24 June 2008

14% of Americans Don’t Believe in an Intelligent Designer

DaveScot

In the latest Gallup poll in a 26-year series asking the same questions, only 14% of Americans are chance worshippers when it comes to evolution. The other 86% believe an intelligent agent was involved. Of course the poll names the intelligent agent “God” but you know what my old pal William Shakespeare had [...]

23 June 2008

Does Naturalism Aid the Environment?

Joel Borofsky

Cross posted at The Christian Watershed

One of the biggest issues trends in the West – especially in America – is for people to go ‘green’ in what they do. Whether it be from getting a hybrid vehicle, to eating organic foods, to just installing energy efficient light bulbs, it is not considered chic to be [...]

22 June 2008

The History Channel: “How Life Began”

GilDodgen

I watch very little television, but I enjoy The History Channel (THC). I’ve learned a lot from it. When it comes to hard science and engineering they do a very good job. I’ve particularly enjoyed their programs about the history of aviation, since I’m a software engineer in the aerospace R&D industry with hundreds of [...]

22 June 2008

Jason Rosenhouse’s Love/Hate Relationship with Ken Miller

DaveScot

This is funny stuff. Jason Rosenhouse, an incurable chance worshipper, fawns over Ken Miller’s gratuitous ID bashing, then goes all negative when Miller starts mouthing telic code-phrases like “the universe was waiting for us” and that “a human-like intelligence was the inevitable result of evolution”. Go to Rosenhouse’s blog at the link above [...]

22 June 2008

TWO BAD WAYS TO ATTACK INTELLIGENT DESIGN AND ?? TWO GOOD ONES

idnet.com.au

In his excellent paper, Jeffrey Koperski argues very well that ID has been unjustifiably excluded from rational scientific consideration. He says that motives imputed to ID proponents should not color consideration of the validity of the theory, and that excluding a theory on definitional grounds is not historically or logically valid. He argues not so well that ID [...]

21 June 2008

Theistic Evolutionists, Your Position Is Incoherent — But We Can Help You!

Thomas Cudworth

In this, my first column for Uncommon Descent, I’d like to address what seems to be a fundamental contradiction running through the writings of many “theistic evolutionists,” and propose an adjustment to their theoretical framework.
 
Critics of theistic evolution (TE) have often suggested that theistic evolutionists (TEs) have to put themselves through mental contortions in order to remain Christian [...]

21 June 2008

Legacy media on the way out quite soon, says tech guru - how will that affect the ID controversy?

O'Leary

Paul Gillin, a veteran technology journalist and formerly editor-in-chief of ComputerWorld, thinks that legacy mainstream media (MSM) are toast.
Sure, lots of people think so, and yet another techhead’s view wouldn’t matter - except that I keep hearing the same thing from journalists who hoped it wasn’t true, and used to say it wasn’t. From Gilpin:
Why [...]

21 June 2008

Did the Allies really defeat the Nazis?

Joel Borofsky

Cross-posted at The Christian Watershed
 
On May 8, 1945 the German government officially surrendered to the Allied Forces, thus ending the War in Europe (the War in the Pacific would continue another three months). The Nazis was a horrible government that aside from its treatment of the Jewish people and other “unwanted,” regularly practiced infanticide. Their [...]

21 June 2008

Pressure on Gov. Jindal to support/deny academic freedom

William Dembski

Here are two emails I received, one from the Academic Freedom Consortium, which backs the recent Louisiana legislation allowing public school teachers to present material critical of Darwinian evolution, another from the skeptic society (Center for Inquiry), saying it’s all a ruse for sneaking religion into the science curriculum and therefore violates the First Amendment.
Please [...]

20 June 2008

ID-Compatible Predictions: Foresighted Mechanisms Identified?

Patrick

Core ID and ID-compatible hypotheses have various predictions. For example, there’s the confirmed predictions related to junk DNA and genetic nature of the platypus, the predictions about designer drugs, long-term preservation mechanisms for conserving information that is not currently implemented, and retroviruses being capable of being used to implement designed changes. At this time the [...]

20 June 2008

The Patristic Understanding of Creation — now available!

William Dembski

An anthology that I started ten years ago is, with the help of two good friends and colleagues, finally out. It is titled The Patristic Understanding of Creation: An Anthology of Writings from the Church Fathers on Creation and Design and can be ordered here. For the table of contents, go here. This is the [...]

19 June 2008

English Crop Circle’s Mysterious Pattern Solved

William Dembski

Unraveling these crop circles constitutes a design inference that doesn’t just tell us that something was designed but also tells us something about the knowledge of the designer:

SOURCE: go here.

19 June 2008

“Saving Darwin” — What’s the point?

William Dembski

I’ve known Karl Giberson over a decade. In the early days, he was a respectful critic of ID. That now seems to have changed with the publication of his most recent book, Saving Darwin: How to Be a Christian and Believe in Evolution (go here for the Amazon listing). The subtitle is curious. Ordinarily one [...]

19 June 2008

Evolution now more firmly established than gravity

Granville Sewell

Darwin’s theory of evolution through natural selection, which was already as well established as the theory of gravity, has taken a big leap forward. According to the New Scientist (see Dave Scot’s post earlier today), E.Coli bacteria have evolved the ability to digest citrate, after only
44,000 generations. “It’s the [...]

19 June 2008

Theistic Evolution - A Pact with the Devil?

DaveScot

Since I don’t believe in angels, devils, and things of that nature understand that the devil in the title is a metaphor for positive atheists. I wanted to point out that as soon as the atheists have vanquished the more blatant god bothering creationists from post-modern western civilization they’re going to go after the [...]

19 June 2008

New Scientist: “the first time evolution has been caught in the act”

DaveScot

In New Scientist we find the following article:
Bacteria make major evolutionary shift in the lab
A major evolutionary innovation has unfurled right in front of researchers’ eyes. It’s the first time evolution has been caught in the act of making such a rare and complex new trait.
This is in reference to the E. coli culture in [...]

18 June 2008

Teaching the Non-Controversy — An Immodest Proposal

William Dembski

There’s an interesting story in today’s Washington Times (go here) on Louisiana’s new science policy (shortly to be signed into law by Governor Jindal) advocating that both strengths and weaknesses of evolutionary theory be taught in the public school science curriculum.
The other side (ACLU, NCSE, Americans United for Separation of Church and State, etc.) [...]

18 June 2008

Theistic Darwinists blitzkrieg the ID movement

scordova

In the month of June we have:
Saving Darwin: How to Be a Christian and Believe in Evolution (Hardcover) by Karl Giberson, released June 10, 2008.
Only a Theory: Evolution and the Battle for America’s Soul (Hardcover) by Ken Miller, released June 12, 2008.
Thank God for Evolution: How the Marriage of Science and Religion Will Transform [...]

18 June 2008

Darwinist Behavior in a Nutshell

Patrick

I watched Miller on the Colbert Report last night. Then I saw this comic. Interesting parallels…

17 June 2008

Michael Ruse on Ken Miller’s New Book (Or, Truth and Beauty Versus Lies and Ugliness)

GilDodgen

Michael Ruse writes:
“Ken Miller’s new book, Only a Theory, Evolution and the Battle for America’s Soul, is everything we have come to expect from him — informed, witty, and above all deeply serious about matters of concern to us all. He takes so-called intelligent design theory apart, piece by piece, showing it for the sham [...]