Uncommon Descent

Archive for May, 2008

14 May 2008

Are materialists starting to understand that their system is collapsing?

O'Leary

In “The Neural Buddhists” (New York Times, May 13, 2008), David Brooks (yes, he of the BoBos, the bohemian bourgeois*) references Tom Wolfe’s dramatic 1996 article “Sorry, but your soul just died,”
.. in which he captured the militant materialism of some modern scientists.To these self-confident researchers, the idea that the spirit might exist apart from […]

14 May 2008

Emulating the “Appearance” of Design in Nature

Mario A. Lopez

Flagella-like Propulsion for Microrobots Using a Nanocoil and a Rotating Electromagnetic Field
Bell, D.J.   Leutenegger, S.   Hammar, K.M.   Dong, L.X.   Nelson, B.J.  
Inst. of Robotics & Intelligent Syst., ETH Zurich
Abstract
A propulsion system similar in size and motion to the helical bacterial flagella motor is presented. The system consists of a magnetic nanocoil as a propeller (27 nm […]

13 May 2008

Take This Survey: If SETI found ET, would that destroy your faith?

O'Leary

What difference would a real live ET make to your faith (whatever it is?)
Ted Peters, a researcher in the field of science and religion and author of SCIENCE, THEOLOGY, AND ETHICS (Ashgate 2003), is conducting a survey. The central question is this: Would contact with extraterrestrial intelligent life affect religion on earth? Would you be […]

13 May 2008

Baylor tenure controversy: Here’s a dollar, google me a scholar - and other news

O'Leary

Recently, Mark Bergin of World Magazine tried a novel approach to the Baylor tenure controversy:
Employing Google’s scholar-specific search engine, which limits results to academic journals, WORLD performed controlled searches for the names of each of this year’s 30 tenure candidates. In general, those faculty members receiving tenure have published with greater frequency since arriving at […]

12 May 2008

Just up at The Design of Life blog: African Eve

O'Leary

Was one woman who lived 150,000 to 200,000 years ago the ancestress of all of us? Science may not be sure, but pop culture is.
Part One: Our Mitochondria: A piece in the puzzle of our origins?
Part Two: What Does Our Mitochondrial DNA Say About Human Ancestry?
Part Three: African Eve - when pop culture falls in […]

12 May 2008

From Darwin to Delegated Fascism

DLH

Richard Pearcey traces how a Darwinian worldview leads to “delegated fascism”. These are critical issues in debating the societal CONSEQUENCES of Evolution vs Intelligent Design, (as distinct from the scientific origin theories themselves.) ———————————
Abortofascism and Free-Market Homicide
By Rick Pearcey, Pro-Existance, May 12, 2008
In a column titled “Atheism and Child Murder,” Dinesh D’Souza comments on his recent […]

11 May 2008

Darwin Correspondence Project

Mario A. Lopez

From Darwin and design: historical essay:
“The only distinct meaning of the word ‘natural’ is stated , fixed or settled ; since what is natural as much requires and presupposes an intelligent agent to render it so, i.e. to effect it continually or at stated times, as what is supernatural or miraculous does to effect it […]

11 May 2008

“They really fear that, so they are prudent, some in good faith, some for calculated fear of being cast out of the scientific community.”

Paul Nelson

Journalist Susan Mazur continues her series of remarkable articles about dissenters from neo-Darwinism with a compelling interview of Massimo Piattelli-Palmarini, professor of cognitive science at the University of Arizona, and co-author (with Jerry Fodor) of the forthcoming book What Darwin Got Wrong.
In the interview, Piattelli-Palmarini points out that many academic biologists muffle their unhappiness with […]

11 May 2008

Real Christians would not have made the Expelled film, right?

O'Leary

The essay by Jeffrey Schloss - excerpted in considerable part here - worriting about the “walls” the Expelled documentary is creating is a classic.
Real Christians, presumably, wouldn’t demand an accounting about the rapidly growing evidence against Darwinism and other materialist isms. And real Christians wouldn’t make a film about the people who get Expelled for doing so.
(Of course, […]

10 May 2008

Discovery exFellow weighs in lightly on Expelled

idnet.com.au

In an essay that is ten times the length of the following extracts, Jeff Schloss, a Christian College professor, weighs in on Expelled. He says Expelled misses the central issues. Unfortunately his essay also missed the central issue. His own personal religious views have led him to write the way he does.

10 May 2008

The Key Thing to Remember

Cornelius Hunter

Last week the Wall Street Journal published a brief list of the scientific problems with evolution, supplied by John West of the Discovery Institute. Scientists are well aware of these problems but it is probably worthwhile to spell them out occasionally in a major newspaper. Even more worthwhile were the responses supplied by evolutionist Dr. […]

10 May 2008

Interesting Graphs of US Temp & Precip History

DaveScot

From NOAA here
These are annual average temperature (top) and precipitation (bottom) in the United States from 1895 through 2007.
The magnitude of change in the trend lines, +1 degree in temperature, +2 inches annual rainfall, is interesting but not nearly as interesting as the slopes being almost identical and straight as an arrow. That’s an […]

10 May 2008

The Rebelution - Do Hard Things

DLH

Alex Harris and Brett Harris are challenging the status quo with: Do Hard Things: A Teenage Rebellion Against Low Expectations, garnering a Foreward by Chuck Norris, 2008, Multnomah Books ISBN-10: 1601421125. What might the prospects be for a hard cover manifesto challenging teenagers to work hard by two 18 year olds? Astonishingly it […]

10 May 2008

Food for Thought

DaveScot

9 May 2008

Higher Ed is higher on WHAT, exactly?

O'Leary

Prof sues disbelieving students. Apparently, they disputed her theories about science … No, in the famous words of Rush Limbaugh, I am not making this up. If I had that kind of imagination, I would be right up there with J.K. Rowlings (rowling in dough, right?)
Also just up at the Overwhelming Evidence blog
The math prof […]

9 May 2008

DaveScot Responds to BarryA

DaveScot

Barry poses the debate topic:
A soldier amuses himself by ripping a baby from his mother’s arms and tossing it in the air and catching it on a bayonet.
Resolved, it is self-evident that the soldier’s action is wrong in all places and at all times.
However, Barry restricts the range of answers by not allowing anyone to […]

9 May 2008

Nancy Pearcey at Beyond Expelled

DLH

At the Beyond Expelled worldview conference, Nancy Pearcey explored the impact of evolution vs ID. She describes skeptic Michael Shermer’s conversion to evolution & Scarlett Johansson’s acting on belief in evolution.
—————-
The intelligent design of life
Nancy Pearcey tells crowd that Darwinism has evolved into more than just a theory (with VIDEO)
Rachel Kyler, Thursday May 8th, 2008
NICEVILLE […]

8 May 2008

Baylor faculty senate nixes President Lilley’s tenure decisions … so is Lilley history?

O'Leary

Tim Woods of the Waco Herald Tribune dropped another bombshell when he revealed yesterday,
Baylor University’s faculty senate Tuesday passed a “failure of shared governance” resolution sharply critical of the administrative style of President John Lilley.
The action came during a meeting lasting three hours and 45 minutes, after which senate chairman Matt Cordon said faculty morale […]

8 May 2008

EXPELLED “stars” in the IMDb

William Dembski

The Internet Movie Database (IMDb) has a new set of entries as a result of Ben Stein’s EXPELLED. And then there are some, like Richard Dawkins, who have a long history in the IMDb:

8 May 2008

Intelligent Design Myth #486 - “ID is politically motivated”

Joel Borofsky

ID is merely a politically motivated agenda that is meant to further the cause of the far right Republicans.
One common objection against ID is that it is merely a tool of the scary Right Wing political party. As the theory goes, the Religious Right is attempting to get ID snuck into classrooms in order to […]

8 May 2008

Kimura and the Adriatic Lizards

PaV

Over at Panda’s Thumb, they are taking issue with the values for selection probabilities of neutral and advantageous mutations that Sal has taken from Kimura and Ohta’s “Theoretical Aspects of Population Genetics”. Since there was a link that provided a ‘look-see’ inside the book, I did so. Well, what I found was very […]

8 May 2008

Is There At Least One Self-Evident Moral Truth?

BarryA

Many scholars believe Dostoevsky’s The Brothers Karamazov is the greatest novel ever written.  I don’t know if that is true.  I am not qualified to judge, but I do know the novel moved me as no other ever has.  So I was intrigued when SteveB referred to a passage from the novel in a comment to my […]

7 May 2008

The Theistic Necessity in the Acquisition of Knowledge

Joel Borofsky

This is cross posted from my own site, The Christian Watershed. To read the rest, please follow the link at the bottom. 
Let me preface this by saying that even though I show how Christianity fits the criteria for warrant, I believe any theistic belief can fit this criteria. In other words, Christianity does not […]

7 May 2008

No Rights for Plants - a necessary factor for the holocaust

DaveScot

As the prior article here talks about some moonbats in the Swiss government have concocted a set of rights for living things that even includes plants’ rights.
This appears to be relevant to some other hot-button topics here in recent days.
First of all it occurs to me that for the holocaust to happen it was a […]

7 May 2008

Plant rights (yes, really!), ape rights - it’s all really just “bureaucracy rights” - also the latest at Design of Life

O'Leary

In “The Silent Scream of the Apsparagus,” old-fashioned liberal and publisher Wesley J. Smith charts the course of “rights” to its inevitable conclusion: plant rights, at least in Switzerland:
A few years ago the Swiss added to their national constitution a provision requiring “account to be taken of the dignity of creation when handling animals, plants […]

7 May 2008

When all else fails - mock them

Joel Borofsky

Cross posted over at “The Christian Watershed.”

 A few years ago I was an assistant coach to a high school debate class. One common thing that must be drilled into the heads of high school debaters is to do their best to avoid insulting the other team. I didn’t always follow this advice in high school […]

7 May 2008

Ben Stein’s Dangerous Idea

DLH

Robert Meyer provides thought provoking insight into the major issues surrounding Expelled.
————————————-
Ben Stein’s Dangerous Idea
Robert Meyer, May 6, 2008, New Media Alliance - Robert E. Meyer
Ben Stein has a dangerous idea. His idea is that professors and teachers who express skepticism about Darwinism are likely to find themselves not granted tenure, castigated and ridiculed, and […]

6 May 2008

BarryA Responds to DaveScot

BarryA

In Bass Ackwards Darwinism (below) my friend DaveScott writes:
 ”Good people do good things.  Evil people do evil things.  Knowledge (like Darwinian evolution and the recipe for dynamite) is inanimate and can be employed by good people for good things and evil people for evil things.”
The issue is not whether “good” people do good things.  Of […]

6 May 2008

Who’s in it for the money?

William Dembski

Critics of the ID movement often complain that we’re fabulously well funded by right-wing extremists and in it for our own aggrandizement. Fortunately, money leaves a trail. When one follows it, Darwinists seem to be doing much better financially than ID theorists (perhaps an indication that they are serving Mammon more faithfully). Let’s consider a […]

6 May 2008

David Sedley’s Creationism and Its Critics in Antiquity

Paul Nelson

Another fascinating book I’m finding hard to put down is David Sedley’s masterful treatment of ancient Greek debates about intelligent design, Creationism and Its Critics in Antiquity (University of California Press, 2008). What Sedley means by “creationism” is not the Henry Morris / ICR / […]

6 May 2008

Let’s say Darwin was necessary for the holocaust

DaveScot

Let’s say that Darwin’s theory of evolution was a necessary factor for the holocaust.
Now class, what science journal should we try to publish this in? Anyone? Anyone?