Uncommon Descent

Archive for October, 2006

31 October 2006

ID on South Park?

crandaddy

South Park creators Trey Parker and Matt Stone–two guys who are not exactly known for refraining from pushing buttons–have made an episode of the show which addresses the topic of opposition to evolution in public schools. It airs tomorrow night at 10:00 EST (9:00 PST) on Comedy Central. Go here for a synopsis […]

31 October 2006

Turkish Education Minister Supports ID

William Dembski

Mustafa Akyol is some one you should know. Check out his blog, where he describes this latest development in Turkey: http://www.thewhitepath.com/archives/2006/10/turkish_minister_supports_intelligent_design.php.

30 October 2006

P. Z. Myers — does he have a clue how bad this looks?

William Dembski

It’s hard to find a Darwinist more extreme than P. Z. Myers (though they do exist). Darwinian extremists like Myers are the reason these people are so hard to parody (see http://cedros.globat.com/~thebrites.org/index.htm, The Brites, which has temporarily closed its doors).
Have a look at Myers’s most recent escapades: http://www.townhall.com/Columnists/MikeSAdams/2006/10/30/philippians_413. I want to encourage discussion not so […]

30 October 2006

William Dembski and 3 IDers cited in a significant OOL peer-reviewed article by Trevors and Abel

scordova

Accepted July 2006
Physics of Life Reviews
[Update: thanks to Todd for a link to the full paper:]
Self-organization vs. self-ordering events in life-origin models
[Update: IDers Charles Thaxton, Walter Bradley, and R.L. Olsen were cited as well!! They wrote the book in 1984 which is considered the beginning of the modern ID movement. […]

29 October 2006

Harvard’s origin of life project: Taking intelligent design seriously - sure, but what follows?

O'Leary

Gareth Cook’s article on the new Harvard origin of life project in the Boston Globe, reads like a press release (except for the very end where he actually quotes Michael Behe). Bill  blogged on it, wondering how seriously they would take any evidence of intelligent design.
Starting with $1 million a year, we are told, Harvard […]

29 October 2006

Harvard’s “Origin of Life in the Universe Initiative”

William Dembski

How much play do you think ID is going to get in Harvard’s new origin of life initiative:
President Bush recently said intelligent design should be discussed in schools, along with evolution. Like intelligent design, the Harvard project begins with awe at the nature of life, and with an admission that, almost 150 years after Charles […]

28 October 2006

Intelligent design requires evidence: Ah, but what can be considered evidence?

O'Leary

Recently, an ID-friendly scientist assured me that intelligent design would easily be accepted if only the ID guys would come up with evidence. To my mind, that shows the difficulty people have in understanding what is at stake: the very question of what may count as evidence. Here is how I replied:   

Bench science, like book […]

27 October 2006

[Request:] Need to quote-mine Gould

William Dembski

I seem to recall that Stephen Jay Gould, when pressed about his views on evolution before his death, remarked that he was a “Darwinian” or “Darwinist.” Can someone provide me with the exact quote as well as with the exact reference? (The context: I’m writing about punctuated equilibrium being at best a slight variant of […]

27 October 2006

Transcript of David Quinn’s shredding of Dawkins

William Dembski

Earlier a link to the mp3 audio file of the Quinn v. Dawkins radio debate was posted on this blog. The following link has the transcript. Quinn provides an object lesson in how to take apart village atheists.
http://catholiceducation.org/articles/science/sc0086.htm

27 October 2006

In evolutionary terms, is religion so bad?

William Dembski

The Dawkins rampage against religion raises the question why religion in the first place? On strict evolutionary grounds, isn’t religion an adaptation that offers humans survival and reproductive advantages? It’s is not at all clear that atheism offers similar benefits (how many Dawkins-style village atheists were there among our hunter-gatherer ancestors?).
Consider, for instance, the […]

26 October 2006

The Root of All Evil?

GilDodgen

I am Richard Dawkins’ worst nightmare — a former militant atheist and Darwinist, who finally realized that everything he believed about everything that mattered was wrong. My conversion came from many sources, too numerous to outline in a brief post, but one of them was reason and examination of the evidence.
Since my conversion I have […]

26 October 2006

Dawkins’ “God Delusion” considers ID science - false science, Dawkins also pronounces on free will and child sex abuse

O'Leary

At Vere loqui, Martin Cothran notes that Richard Dawkins’The God Delusion, provides ammunition to ID advocates.
ID theorists are familiar with the accusation that ID is both unfalsifiable and anyway, already falsified. (The fact that the two claims can be maintained comfortably at once illustrates the extent to which materialism and Darwinism function as ideologies. In […]

24 October 2006

WIRED MAGAZINE: “The Church of the Non-Believers” by Gary Wolf

William Dembski

Interesting article in WIRED on the unholy trinity Dawkins-Dennett-Harris. Their atheist extremism may be selling books but is it winning converts?
. . . The New Atheists will not let us off the hook simply because we are not doctrinaire believers. They condemn not just belief in God but respect for belief in God. Religion is […]

24 October 2006

[anecdote 2004] Nobel Laureate given standing ovation after slamming Darwinism during a graduation ceremony

scordova

In preparing a letter to the editor of UVa magazine, I was researching the case of 1996 Nobel Laureate in Chemistry, Richard Smalley. I was astonished to discover that he delivered an anti-Darwinian speech during a graduation ceremony and apparently received a standing ovation. I also thought it an appropriate time to remember […]

24 October 2006

Legacy mainstream media: The ID guys’ best friends?

O'Leary

Courtesy of the McLaurin Institute, I gave a talk last Thursday night at the Murphy Building of the University of Minnesota’s journalism school, on how North American media cover the intelligent design controversy and why the media are really the ID guys’ most useful unintentional ally - second only to Richard Dawkins, in my view. […]

23 October 2006

What’s Wrong With Gap Arguments, Anyway?

GilDodgen

ID proponents are often accused of using “God-of-the-gaps” arguments. Of course, there are positive arguments for inferences to design in the natural world, but Del Ratzsch makes an interesting point about gap arguments in this interview.
He comments:
…the SETI program is a gap-searching project — trying to find signals which nature alone couldn’t or wouldn’t produce, […]

23 October 2006

The British Centre for Science Education unmasked

William Dembski

Blogger David Anderson, who has a first-class degree in Mathematics from Oxford University, is putting a bit of pressure on the British Centre for Science Education, quite successfully, it seems. He has uncovered good evidence that they have been less than forthright in the course of some recent parliamentary lobbying:
http://bcse-revealed.blogspot.com

23 October 2006

Someone finally said it: “Dawkins’s hysterical scientism”

O'Leary

Marilynne Robinson, author of Gilead, which won both the 2004 Pulitzer Prize for fiction and 2005 National Book Critics Circle award, says what needs to be said, and no more, about Oxford Professor of the Public Understanding of Science Richard Dawkins’ inane crusade against religion And she says it brilliantly in “Hysterical scientism: The ecstasy […]

22 October 2006

The future of human evolution

William Dembski

In reading the following, keep in mind that evolutionists who put out this drivel are themselves evolutionary dead ends, destined for the dustbin of history:
Evolutionary theorist Oliver Curry of the London School of Economics expects a genetic upper class and a dim-witted underclass to emerge.
The human race would peak in the year 3000, he […]

20 October 2006

Dawkins on free will

William Dembski

The first paragraph of the following quote appeared in a comment to Gil Dodgen’s post on the Quinn v. Dawkins debate on Irish radio. The succeeding paragraph is quite illuminating and included here. Question: What evidence (since Dawkins is so big on evidence) would help us to decide whether attributing responsibility to others for their […]

20 October 2006

Ummm….I think Wikipedia has the Wellses confused.

crandaddy

At least I hope it’s just confusion. If not, then it looks an awful lot like persecution of a man for his personal views. To see what I’m talking about, go here. It’s stuff like this that makes me glad to see that a rival to Wikipedia is “days away from launching” […]

20 October 2006

Putting the Cart Before the Horse

Patrick

When it comes to discussing open systems aren’t we getting a little ahead of ourselves here? There are still some very basic problems to solve before getting into hand-waving over the evolution of computers and human minds.
http://www.pnas.org/cgi/content/abstract/0605863103v1
Solutions with as little as 1% enantiomeric excess (ee) of D- or L-phenylalanine are amplified to 90% ee […]

20 October 2006

Colbert Has Fun With Dawkins’s Delusions

Scottus

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hO9OFOcdB0Q
Enjoy.

19 October 2006

Richard Dawkins Versus David Quinn

GilDodgen

Sorry for the serial posts, but so much is happening. David Quinn, a well-known Catholic commentator and journalist in Ireland recently debated Richard Dawkins on Irish radio.
Dawkins comments in the debate: “I’m not interested in free will… Just as before Darwin, biology was a mystery — Darwin solved that…”
David Quinn is one sharp cookie. (I […]

19 October 2006

Interesting Quotes From Biology Textbooks

GilDodgen

For those who are convinced that Darwinism has no meaningful philosophical or theological implications I offer the following quotes from biology textbooks. Special thanks go to ID colleague Casey Luskin.

19 October 2006

Can ANYTHING Happen in an Open System?

GilDodgen

In a previous UD post I commented on an article by mathematician Granville Sewell, “A Mathematician’s View of Evolution.” Since then Granville and I have corresponded and he forwarded a follow-up piece entitled, “Can Anything Happen in an Open System?”
The essence of the thesis is as follows:
If an increase in order is extremely improbable when […]

19 October 2006

Francis Collins: “I greatly respect William Dembski…best wishes to Salvador Cordova and the IDEA club”

scordova

I mentioned earlier my delight that the GMU Provost was willing to put his good name behind Francis Collins book tour: GMU Provost hosts The Language of God.
Well, the talk happened and it was amazing! Francis Collins gave his Christian testimony tonight pretty much along the lines of his book. He recounted […]

18 October 2006

The Definition of Life

Patrick

http://www.ffame.org/sbenner/cochembiol8.672-689.pdf
The opening discussion:
To decide whether life has a common chemical plan, we must decide what life is. A panel assembled by NASA in 1994 was one of many groups to ponder this question. The panel defined life as a ‘chemical system capable of Darwinian evolution’ [16]. This definition, which follows an earlier definition by Sagan […]

18 October 2006

Darwin Loves You (and has a wonderful plan for your life!)

William Dembski

George Levine has a new book, Darwin Loves You. The book is silly and superficial, and would not be worth notice except that it serves as Exhibit A for the fact that Darwinism has become a religion, or at least, a “comprehensive doctrine” in the sense of Rawls (John, not Lou), and hence NOT something […]

18 October 2006

How many evolutionary biologists are really Dawkins-ites?

O'Leary

Non-Darwinian evolutionary biologists may start to speak up in greater numbers as more ID conferences are held. An ID conference sometimes spotlights those who do not want to be called Darwinists or Darwinians, irrespective of their views on ID.
Readers may recall that at our University of Toronto ID conference a couple of weekends ago, I […]

18 October 2006

Michael Behe on the SciPhi Show

scordova

The Sci Phi Show interview with Michael Behe is now available! Check it out!
Here is the link Michael Behe on Sci Phi Show.